The Leg Chair is the chair directly to Bill Schulz's left, closest to the camera. It is always occupied by an attractive female guest, with very rare exceptions. While most guests think nothing of it, Imogen Lloyd Webber continually stated that she didn't like it and referenced this fact on the show numerous times.
At least six times has the Leg Chair been occupied by a man:
- A lederhosen-clad Bill Schulz on October 30, 2009 (Halloween episode)
- Oderus Urungus on December 14, 2009
- Kurt Loder on the Andrew Breitbart Tribute Episode (March 1, 2012)
- Penn Jillette on April 23, 2012
- Bill Schulz on February 11, 2013
- Mike Spasiuk on April 27, 2013 (There was an extra seat available for that episode since scheduled guest Nick DiPaolo got stuck in a traffic jam and missed the taping.)