Guess the Story
Last Appearance 2012

Guess the Story was a recurring segment on Red Eye. In this segment, an obscure piece of video was shown and the four panelists had to guess what's going on in the video clip. It was generally used to chew up time late in the show, but it was occasionally used earlier, even in the A block.

At least one person has come up with the correct answer, Diane Macedo on February 22, 2011, although she had seen the video clip earlier in the day.